Appropriate Immigration Reform: Stop The Hate and Fear-Mongerring

A study, commissioned by the Americans for Immigration Reform Task Force (part of the Greater Houston Partnership), found that if 8.1 undocumented workers (otherwise knows as illegal immigrants) left overnight, the U.S. would lose $1.8 trillion in annual spending, according to today’s Houston Chronicle. While the task force has a vested interest in highlighting the detrimental effects of the absence of illegal immigrants, the study presents a merited discussion on the positive aspects of their inclusion in American society.

There has been much fear-mongering in the media over the ethics of allowing undocumented workers within our borders and workplaces. They’re taking jobs from American citizens! There are criminals among them! They don’t speak English and will marry our daughters! The lack of reasoning among those who cherry-pick statistics and facts and then use them as scare tactics for either political purposes or sensationalist media strategies is appalling.

While comprehensive immigration reform should undoubtedly be a priority of our legislative leaders, simply building a wall and kicking out “aliens” would not only NOT address our current problems, it would have a hugely negative impact on the farming, construction, restaurant, meatpacking and many other industries already under severe economic strain. Unfortunately, undocumented workers can be at a tremendous disadvantage in the workplace, receiving unfair wages and facing dangerous working conditions – a much more cogent motivation for reform than the “drain on our economy” argument used by the media crazies and right-wing politicians looking for that next leg up during election season.

The vast majority of our families were at one time undocumented and arrived in the U.S. without adhering to our strict immigration laws. Truth be told, the United States has a strong economy, capable of absorbing the millions of illegal immigrants – a large percentage of whom have been in here for years. Much of the media coverage and the shouting from the right wing is simply unfounded propaganda.

Anna Quindlen wrote in Newsweek last August that Mayor Bloomberg “testified before a Senate committee that they (undocumented workers) are the linchpin of his city’s economy.” She went on to write that new businesses are started by Latinos at a rate three times the national average.

Immigration reform cannot simply focus on kicking them out, having them pay a fine and then they can return. This is a very short-sighted non-solution that would do more harm than good. The path to becoming a citizen must be cheaper, shorter and less bureaucratic. Only then will immigrants opt for the legal route rather than the back alleys. This will also help separate the well-intentioned hard workers (that make up the vast majority of illegal immigrants) from the few bad eggs.

For any of us to claim that the U.S. and the possibilities available here are ours and ours alone is absurd. Numbers, studies and statistics are continually manipulated by all sides for ulterior motives, leaving us the individual duty of researching and judging for ourselves where the solutions lay. Talking heads are merely hurdles for the truth. Unreasonable fears implanted in today’s society prevent many from appreciating the enormous cultural and economic value undocumented workers present. For example, the contribution by these workers to Social Security annually is in the billions, yet they themselves will not benefit from these payments.

I live in Texas and think we should try to extend a helping hand rather than flout the ideals that once made our country great. Let’s be cool about this, people. Get of the ineffective Hate Train and stop yelling, “Off with their heads!” These tactics have been historical failures. Undocumented workers will not stop coming, wall or no. And if we offer a voice and protection and fairness in exchange for the meeting of reasonable, legal demands, only then will the situation benefit all parties involved.


4 Responses to “Appropriate Immigration Reform: Stop The Hate and Fear-Mongerring”

  1. 2 Meredith
    May 21, 2008 at 11:13 am

    I watched this youtube clip and:
    1. I disagree wholeheartedly with the assertion from the CIS rep. Steven Camarota that the government assumes immigrants “will have wages and resulting taxes as high as natives.” The government is very well aware that immigrants are much more likely to have jobs that pay minimum wage or below as they have no legal protection.
    2. The video only once sites a specific source of the government claims they continually refute in the video.
    3. The CIS’ executive director, Mark Kirkorkian contributes to conservative publication National Review, giving question to any idea that the CIS is non-partisan.
    4. I don’t argue that we need high-levels of immigration to offset America’s aging population. That’s more of a minor issue in the immigration debate. The major issue is illegal immigration has always occurred and will continue to do so if we do not reform our immigration standards to effectively deal with the influx of people and those already here. Kicking them out and putting up a wall is impossible, improbable and simply wouldn’t work. People will always find a way to circumnavigate physical barriers and large men with guns. It’s the nature of humanity.

  2. 3 rfabro
    December 27, 2008 at 4:24 pm

    “The vast majority of our families were at one time undocumented and arrived in the U.S.”

    That is a LIE! Come on lying, liar, ‘fess up! If you’re referring to immigrant waves of the past,they were all documented and legal!

  3. January 8, 2009 at 10:37 pm

    lying liar, fess up?!? are you on meds? do you think i’m part of some huge conspiracy providing misinformation regarding historical immigration statistics. jeez, take a pill.

    past immigration waves were legal because there was no such thing as illegal immigration. almost all immigrants who came to our shores were admitted and passports were not required. stringent requirements were only put in place in the 1920’s and later.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Scarlet Letter of Atheism


Bloggers' Rights at EFF

Blog Stats

  • 95,975 hits
WordPress Political Blogger

Top Clicks

  • None

%d bloggers like this: